Beef New York Strip · Reverse-Searing

Reverse-Searing Beef New York Strip

Timing, temperature, and the cues that decide doneness for beef new york strip.

40min
Cook Time
275°F / 135°C
Pan Temperature
0.3 lb / 5 oz / 140 g
Portion Weight
Per adult serving
120-160°F / 50-70°C
Internal Temperature
Rare to Well Done

Step-by-Step Instructions

  1. 1Remove NY strip from refrigerator and let come to room temperature (30 minutes)
  2. 2Season generously with salt and pepper on both sides
  3. 3Preheat oven to 275°F / 135°C
  4. 4Place NY strip on wire rack over baking sheet
  5. 5Bake 20-40 minutes until desired doneness
  6. 6Check internal temperature reaches 120-160°F / 50-70°C (rare to well done)
  7. 7Remove from oven and let rest while heating skillet
  8. 8Heat cast iron skillet over high heat until smoking
  9. 9Add oil and sear NY strip 1-2 minutes per side
  10. 10Remove when desired doneness reached
  11. 11Check internal temperature reaches 120-160°F / 50-70°C (rare to well done)
  12. 12Let rest 5 minutes before slicing

Expert Tips for Reverse-Searing

  • Perfect for thick NY strips (1.5 inches or more)
  • Creates perfectly even doneness throughout
  • Use a meat thermometer for precision
  • The slow cooking ensures tender results

Beef New York Strip Temperature Guide

DonenessTemperatureDescription
Rare120°F / 50°CCool red center, very soft texture
Medium Rare130°F / 55°CWarm red center, tender and juicy
Medium140°F / 60°CWarm pink center, slightly firmer texture
Medium Well150°F / 65°CLight pink center, firm texture
Well Done160°F / 70°CBrown throughout, firm texture

Beef New York Strip Safety Guidelines

Important food safety practices when handling and cooking beef new york strip.

Cook to proper internal temperature

Use food thermometer

Remember

When in doubt, use a food thermometer. It's the only reliable way to ensure your beef new york strip is safely cooked and delicious.

Other Ways to Cook Beef New York Strip

Grilling

Grilling Beef New York Strip

Cook Time
15min
Grill Temperature
High
450-500°F / 232-260°C
Internal Temperature
120-160°F / 50-70°C
Rare to Well Done
Read the guide

Pan-Searing

Pan-Searing Beef New York Strip

Cook Time
10min
Pan Temperature
High
350-400°F / 175-200°C
Internal Temperature
120-160°F / 50-70°C
Rare to Well Done
Read the guide

Broiling

Broiling Beef New York Strip

Cook Time
15min
Broiler Temperature
500°F / 260°C
Internal Temperature
120-160°F / 50-70°C
Rare to Well Done
Read the guide

Sous-vide

Sous-vide Beef New York Strip

Cook Time
2h
Cooking Temperature
130°F / 55°C
Internal Temperature
120-160°F / 50-70°C
Rare to Well Done
Read the guide

Smoking

Smoking Beef New York Strip

Cook Time
1h30min
Smoker Temperature
225°F / 105°C
Internal Temperature
120-160°F / 50-70°C
Rare to Well Done
Read the guide

Keep Exploring

Other categories

Cooking guides across other food categories

Category

Poultry

Chicken, turkey, duck with safe cooking guidelines

Category

Seafood

Fresh fish and shellfish cooking guides

Category

Vegetables

Healthy vegetable cooking techniques

Reverse-searing is sous-vide's no-equipment alternative, a low oven brings the strip to just under target, then a screaming pan finishes it with crust. The result is nearly identical doneness, a noticeably better sear, and zero gear beyond an oven and a thermometer.

I · Why This Method

Why It Works

Traditional searing of a thick steak forces you to over-cook the outside to get the inside to temperature. Reverse-searing flips the sequence: bring the interior up to 5–10°F under your target in a low oven, then sear the dry, ambient-temperature surface for 60–90 seconds per side over very high heat. Because the surface is dry and warm by the time it hits the pan, not cold and wet from the fridge, the Maillard crust forms before any heat has time to conduct inward. You get the same edge-to-edge medium-rare as sous-vide with a sear that's arguably more flavour-dense, no circulator required.

II · Targets

Time & Temperature

The two numbers are the oven temperature (low, 250–275°F) and the pull temperature (5–10°F below your final target). The cook time follows from steak thickness; the sear is always 60–90 seconds per side over the hottest pan you can produce.

Oven temperature
250°F / 120°C

Low enough that the surface barely darkens during the oven phase, leaving room for the sear to do all the browning work. 275°F is acceptable for speed; above 300°F, the gap between oven and sear narrows and you lose the technique's advantage.

Pull temperature (rare final)
115°F / 46°C

Final reading after rest and sear, 125°F / 52°C.

Pull temperature (medium-rare final, recommended)
120°F / 49°C

Final reading after rest and sear, 130°F / 54°C.

Pull temperature (medium final)
125°F / 52°C

Final reading after rest and sear, 135°F / 57°C.

Oven time, 1 in / 2.5 cm steak
15 – 20 minutes

Too thin for the method's strengths, sous-vide or simple pan-sear are easier choices.

Oven time, 1.5 in / 3.8 cm steak
25 – 35 minutes

The thickness where reverse-sear starts to shine.

Oven time, 2 in / 5 cm steak
40 – 50 minutes

The classic reverse-sear application. Sous-vide is faster but the dry oven phase produces a crisper surface that sears better.

Sear time
60 – 90 seconds per side

Cast iron over highest heat, oil shimmering and wisping. Total sear time should not exceed 3 minutes; longer and the cooked band creeps inward.

III · Doneness

How to Tell It's Done

  • ✓ The probe thermometer at the steak's geometric centre reads your pull temperature exactly, at this stage you stop the oven phase
  • ✓ The surface has gone from raw-red to a dry, dull brownish-red as the oven phase finishes, that dryness is what enables the sear
  • ✓ After the sear, the crust is mahogany brown and the cross-section shows a hair-thin (1–3 mm) gradient from crust to the interior doneness
  • ✓ The steak feels firm and bouncy to fingertip pressure, not soft or fleshy
  • ✓ Juices that bead at the cut surface look rosé and stay rosé as the steak rests, clear juice means medium or further

IV · Kit

Equipment That Matters

Wire rack over a rimmed baking sheet

Critical. The rack lets air circulate under the steak so both sides dry evenly in the oven. A steak sitting directly on a sheet pan steams on the bottom and won't sear properly there.

Oven-safe probe thermometer

Leave the probe in the steak's centre throughout the oven phase. The dial- or app-controlled alarms that beep at a set temperature are the single most useful kitchen tool for this method; an instant-read alone forces you to open the oven repeatedly.

Cast-iron or carbon-steel skillet

Must hold extreme heat. Stainless and aluminium drop in temperature too fast when the steak goes in. The pan should sit on the highest burner setting for 8–10 minutes before searing.

High-smoke-point oil

Grapeseed, refined avocado, beef tallow, or rice bran oil. Olive oil and butter both burn before the pan reaches sear temperature. Save butter for the last 30 seconds of basting.

Kitchen tongs and a stiff spatula

Tongs for handling; the spatula is for pressing the steak flat in the pan if it bows from contraction. A fish spatula works well, wide and thin.

V · Troubleshooting

When Something Goes Wrong

Sear won't develop a real crust
Surface was wet from oven moisture, or the pan wasn't hot enough. Pat the steak aggressively with paper towels after pulling from the oven, then let it sit on the rack for 5 minutes while the pan finishes heating. The pan must be smoking; oil shimmer alone is not hot enough.
Cooked grey band under the crust
Sear took too long, or the steak went into the pan still cold inside. Limit each side to 90 seconds maximum. If your oven was set above 275°F, the surface was already partly cooked when it hit the pan and the sear had less buffer to work with, lower the oven next time.
Steak is over-target when sliced
You pulled it from the oven at your target temperature instead of 5–10°F below. The sear adds 5–10°F of carryover to a thick steak. The "pull at 120°F to land at 130°F" rule assumes you have a 60–90 second sear ahead.
Bottom of the steak overcooks
Steak sat directly on the baking sheet without a rack. Conducted heat from the metal cooks the bottom faster than the surrounding air cooks the top. A wire rack is the single most important piece of kit for this technique.

VI · Pitfalls

Common Mistakes

Setting the oven too high

The whole point of reverse-sear is the gentle, even rise to pull temperature. A 350°F oven cooks the outside of the steak past the cooked band before the centre gets to 120°F, defeating the technique. Stay between 250–275°F.

Skipping the rack

A steak sitting on a baking sheet steams on the bottom and dries on the top, the opposite of what you want. A wire cooling rack costs ten dollars and is the difference between a real reverse-sear and a pseudo one.

Pulling at the target temperature

Unlike sous-vide, reverse-sear has meaningful carryover because the sear adds heat to a steak that was below target to begin with. Pull at 120°F for a 130°F final. The 10°F gap is the sear's working room.

Resting between oven and sear too long

Letting the steak sit for 15 minutes between phases drops its temperature past the point where the sear can warm it back up to target. A 3–5 minute rest is right, long enough to dry the surface and heat the pan, short enough that the interior holds.

Resting after the sear

Like sous-vide, reverse-sear doesn't need a post-sear rest, the slow oven phase has already let juices redistribute and the temperature has equilibrated. Slice and serve. Any rest at this stage just lets the crust soften.

VII · Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

Reverse-sear vs sous-vide, which is better?

Different tools, same destination, slight differences in result. Sous-vide is more precise, the bath cannot overshoot. Reverse-sear gives a noticeably better sear because the surface is dry and warm rather than wet from the bag. Sous-vide is more set-and-forget; reverse-sear requires checking the oven probe. For someone who owns a circulator and uses it often, sous-vide is simpler. For everyone else, reverse-sear delivers 95% of the result with equipment they already own.

Why pull at 120°F when I want 130°F?

The sear adds 5–10°F of carryover, and the residual heat from the warm-but-not-hot interior continues to climb for a minute or two after the steak comes out. Pulling at the final target produces medium when you wanted medium-rare. The 10°F gap is what makes the final number land where you want it.

Can I reverse-sear a 1-inch steak?

Yes, but the method's advantage shrinks. The thinner the steak, the less benefit you get from the gentle oven phase, a 1-inch strip can be cooked perfectly in a hot pan alone with attention. Reverse-sear was developed for thick (1.5"+) steaks where conventional searing leaves an under-cooked centre. For 1-inch steaks, use a simple pan sear or sous-vide briefly.

Should I salt before or after the oven phase?

24 hours before, uncovered on the rack in the fridge. The dry-brine seasons deeply, draws surface moisture out, and gives you the kind of mahogany crust that 5-minute salting can't approach. The rack-in-fridge step doubles as the drying step the oven phase needs.

Can I use a propane torch instead of a pan for the sear?

Yes, especially for steaks that don't fit a pan flat. Sweep from 4–6 inches above the surface, keep moving, and stop the moment the crust looks done. Torches build less flavour than a cast-iron pan (no fond, no basting butter step), but they give the most uniform crust across an irregular surface.

Continue reading: the full method notes

What reverse-sear actually does

Conventional searing of a thick steak is a balancing act between two incompatible goals. The crust wants high heat for a long time; the interior wants low heat or a short time. A 1.5-inch strip in a hot pan develops crust around the same moment the cooked band marches halfway to the centre. The “rest then sear” sequence inherited from mid-century cookbooks doesn’t help much, a 30-minute rest on the counter raises the steak’s surface by less than 5°F, not enough to change the math.

Reverse-sear breaks the trade-off by separating the two phases. The oven phase, at 250–275°F, brings the entire steak from refrigerator- cold to roughly 10°F below the target final temperature, a slow, even rise that produces zero crust but a dry, equilibrated steak. The pan phase, at the highest heat the burner produces, builds the crust in 60–90 seconds on each side. Because the surface is dry and warm rather than wet and cold, the Maillard reaction starts almost instantly; because the total sear time is short, the heat doesn’t have time to conduct inward. The cooked band, the grey-pink gradient between crust and centre, measures 1–3 mm where a conventional sear measures 3–6 mm.

The trick is the temperature gap. Pulling the steak from the oven at 120°F for a 130°F final relies on the sear and residual heat to close the 10°F gap precisely. Done right, the steak slices to near-uniform pink from crust to crust.

When reverse-sear beats sous-vide

For most cooks who already own a sous-vide circulator, the answer is “rarely”, the bath is more set-and-forget and more precise. But reverse-sear has three legitimate advantages.

First, no equipment beyond an oven and a probe thermometer. Sous-vide adds $100+ to the kitchen kit; reverse-sear works with what’s already there.

Second, the dry surface that emerges from a low oven sears more aggressively than the wet surface that emerges from a sous-vide bag. The crust is darker, the flavour denser, and the Maillard compounds develop more completely. The difference is small but real on a side-by-side comparison.

Third, the oven phase forgives small timing errors more readily. A steak that sits in a 250°F oven for an extra 5 minutes goes up 3–4°F; a steak that sits in a 130°F bath for an extra 30 minutes barely moves. Sous-vide is more precise; reverse-sear is more forgiving.

For a 2-inch porterhouse on a holiday dinner with eight people watching, reverse-sear is the right call, the technique is visible, the timing is flexible, and the result is restaurant- grade. For a Tuesday-night strip steak alone in the kitchen, sous-vide wins on simplicity.

The thickness threshold

Reverse-sear is built for thick steaks. Below 1.25 inches, the oven phase is so short (15 minutes or less) that you might as well just sear conventionally. Between 1.25 and 1.5 inches, the technique works but the advantage over conventional searing is modest. Above 1.5 inches, the thickness most steakhouses serve, reverse-sear is the unambiguously best home method short of a circulator.

Most supermarket NY strips run 1 inch thick because that’s what fits the standard retail tray. For reverse-sear specifically, ask the butcher counter to cut you a 1.5- or 2-inch piece. The cost per pound is the same; the cooking result is dramatically different. This is one of the rare cases where butcher-counter shopping over pre-tray-packaged saves more in cooking outcome than it costs in inconvenience.

Sources & further reading